A monthly market brief
The Paper Trail
Observations from the front lines of consumer lending, from Louis Barna, Managing Partner.
Latest issue
Turn the Customer, Not the Car
The operators winning this cycle underwrite two things at once — whether the car survives the loan, and whether the customer is worth keeping
Earlier this year we wrote that the disposable car had killed the old buy-here-pay-here math — two clean turns and out. The best operators have drawn the logical conclusion: stop treating underwriting as a single credit decision made at the sale, and start underwriting two things at once for the life of the loan — whether the vehicle survives the term, and whether the borrower is worth keeping. Here's what that looks like on the lot, what rewarding a performing customer actually takes (and what the market has already tried and botched), and the squeeze forcing everyone to figure it out.
Read the issueEvery issue.
Vol. 1, Issue 5 · October 2026
Turn the Customer, Not the Car
Earlier this year we wrote that the disposable car had killed the old buy-here-pay-here math — two clean turns and out. The best operators have drawn the logical conclusion: stop treating underwriting as a single credit decision made at the sale, and start underwriting two things at once for the life of the loan — whether the vehicle survives the term, and whether the borrower is worth keeping. Here's what that looks like on the lot, what rewarding a performing customer actually takes (and what the market has already tried and botched), and the squeeze forcing everyone to figure it out.
Vol. 1, Issue 4 · August 2026
The Succession Squeeze
A credit squeeze is pushing buy-here-pay-here operators toward the exit just as the natural buyers — the long-time employee, the dealer two blocks over — can't get the financing to take over. Two jaws of the same vise, with demographics only the tailwind. Here are the four ways out.
Vol. 1, Issue 3 · May 2026
Two Turns and Out: How Disposable Cars Are Driving the Voluntary Surrender Wave
Mechanical breakdown has overtaken job loss as the number-one reason borrowers hand back the keys — the first time in at least a decade. The car is breaking faster than the loan, and the old buy-here-pay-here math of turning a unit until the wheels fall off is finished.
Vol. 1, Issue 2 · April 2026
Bolted to the Roof: How Solar Loans Became the Industry's Most Expensive Problem
If you're holding solar loans right now — whether you're a credit union, a bank, or a specialty lender — you already know something is wrong. The calls are coming in. The disputes are stacking up. And the math that made these deals work on origination day doesn't pencil anymore.
Vol. 1, Issue 1 · March 2026
The Squeeze Is Real: Why Subprime Auto Is Getting Hit from Every Direction
If you're in the subprime auto ecosystem right now — whether you're originating, servicing, buying paper, or running a lot — you already feel it. The macro picture is rough. But what's different about this cycle is how many pressures are converging at once. This isn't one problem. It's five of them stacked on top of each other.
Talk to us
Have a portfolio you want us to look at?
Send portfolio-level detail — status mix, balances, seasoning. We’ll come back with what is recoverable and what it would sell for today.